| Artwork part of a Stations of the Cross series by Barbara Barrett |
A crown.
That sign.
Blood.
Mockery.
Abandonment.
The ache of watching someone you love suffer while you can do absolutely nothing to stop it.
Is this what love comes to?
Feel free to keep adding words.
The church has given us language for this day. There are solemn collects and ancient prayers. There are theologies of atonement and redemption, and words like “obedience,” “sacrifice,” and “salvation.”
But before any of that—before any careful doctrine, before any polished sentence—there is deep, deep grief.
There is the animal anguish of it.
The outrage of it.
The terrible, helpless question of it.
Is this what love comes to?
For some of us, it is familiar.
Feelings may rise to the surface. Let them. Episcopalians aren’t so accustomed to raw emotion in church, but we’ll survive.
Now's the time to ask the hard questions.
Why this?
Why is truth so silent while lies seem to shout?
Why is mercy crucified while cruelty walks free?
Why does someone so innocent end up being lied about, bruised, broken, mocked, and thirsty?
Why do people in power wash their hands when they could so easily do the right thing?
Why are scared people so dangerous?
How does a crowd suddenly turn cheer for death?
Violence
Cowardice
Public humiliation
State-sanctioned cruelty
Religious self-protection
The smugness of people who think someone else’s suffering is necessary.
It is all here.
While at the foot of the cross are the ones who love him. They're already grieving deeply.
They’ll be the ones left to grieve when the world goes on.
"He lived!" They'll want to shout to anyone who will listen.
Say his name! For God’s sake, remember him.
Anyone who has ever grieved knows this feeling.
His mother.
His aunt.
Mary Magdalene. The other Mary.
The mysterious beloved disciple.
The ones who cannot fix it.
The ones who cannot argue it away.
The ones who, despite their best efforts, cannot make it meaningful enough to hurt any less.
They just stay.
And maybe the holiest thing anyone can do today is just stay.
Stay when prayers feel useless.
Stay when God feels silent.
Stay when the sky goes dark. When the ground beneath us feels unsteady and unsafe.
Stay when every cell in our body says, run.
Stay when we’re tempted to intellectualize or look for the bright side. To skip ahead to Easter.”
But the church, in her wisdom, does not skip ahead.
There is no alleluia on Good Friday, no triumphant brass.
No pretending that death is not real, that suffering is not cruel, or that grief is tidy and dignified.
Today, grief gets to be grief.
Today, sorrow has a voice.
Today, we are invited to say: "This is wrong!"
Mothers should not have to bury their sons!
The poor and powerless should not be systematically crushed by disproportionately unfair systems.
It is wrong. It is wrong. It is wrong.
If you’re here with your own grief, Good Friday makes room for you.
Not the brave, cleaned-up, well-behaved version.
Just You. With your anger, your questions, your bewilderment, your exhaustion…
The you who still prays and the you who cannot.
The you who says, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” and means it.
Because Jesus has gone there too.
That is the terrible wonder of this day: not that suffering is explained, but that God enters it.
Not from a distance.
Not as a spectator.
Not with good advice.
God enters it with flesh and blood and a breaking heart.
God enters betrayal.
God enters torture.
God enters abandonment.
God enters death.
So, if all you have today is tears, bring them.
If all you have is anger, bring it.
If all you have is silence, bring it.
If all you have is the strength to stand far off and watch, then stand far off and watch.
But know this: your grief has not exiled you from God.
On Good Friday, grief where God is.
And so, we are brought to our knees today, not because we understand, but because we do not.
Not because we are unbroken, but because we are.
Not because grief has been answered, but because grief has been joined by God himself.
This is a brutal day.
Because this is what love has come to.
And we will grieve for as long as it takes…
Thousands of years, in fact. Until we finally grasp the God-honest truth.
You want to know what truth is, Pilate. Look here! What do you see?